Some links in this guide may earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Laundry detergent is one of those products people rarely think hard about — you use it on everything you wear and sleep in, it touches your skin for hours at a time, and most of us have been buying the same brand since college. But conventional detergents are packed with chemicals that have no business being in contact with your skin all day.
Here's what's actually in them, what matters when switching, and which brands pass the bar.
What's Actually in Conventional Laundry Detergent
Synthetic Fragrance
The single biggest problem. "Fragrance" on a label is a legal black box — it can represent a cocktail of hundreds of individual chemicals, none of which the manufacturer is required to disclose. The fragrance industry self-regulates through the International Fragrance Association (IFRA), but IFRA's standards are voluntary and the organization is funded by the very companies it oversees.
Synthetic fragrance ingredients include phthalates (used to make scents last longer — associated with hormone disruption), benzene derivatives, aldehydes, and known allergens. The American Contact Dermatitis Society has named fragrance the allergen of the year multiple times. These compounds don't just wash out of your clothes; they're engineered to linger.
Even products marketed as "lightly scented" or "fresh scent" are using synthetic fragrance. If the label says "fragrance," it's synthetic unless it explicitly says "from essential oils" with the specific oils named.
Optical Brighteners
Optical brighteners (also called fluorescent whitening agents or FWAs) don't actually clean your clothes. They're synthetic chemical compounds that absorb UV light and re-emit it as visible blue-white light, making whites appear brighter and colors more vivid. It's a perceptual trick — they're making your clothes look cleaner, not making them cleaner.
The problem: optical brighteners don't fully rinse out. They deposit on your fabric and stay there in contact with your skin. They're aquatic toxins (classified as harmful to aquatic organisms with long-lasting effects) and are slow to biodegrade. Some are classified as endocrine disruptors. They can cause skin irritation and photosensitivity.
1,4-Dioxane
This one doesn't appear on ingredient labels because it's not intentionally added — it's a byproduct of ethoxylation, a manufacturing process used to make certain surfactants less harsh. Ingredients like sodium laureth sulfate (SLES), PEG compounds, and "eth" suffix surfactants can be contaminated with 1,4-dioxane.
The EPA classifies 1,4-dioxane as a likely human carcinogen. A 2020 study by the EWG found it in common laundry detergents at concentrations up to 47 parts per million — including some products marketed as "natural." There's no maximum legal limit in laundry products.
The fix is a manufacturing step called vacuum stripping that removes residual 1,4-dioxane. Some companies do it, most don't, and most don't disclose either way. Avoiding ethoxylated surfactants altogether (which clean brands do) sidesteps the issue.
Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS) and Sodium Laureth Sulfate (SLES)
SLS is a surfactant — it's what makes detergent foam and helps lift grease. It's not inherently toxic, but it's a known skin irritant, particularly for people with eczema or sensitive skin, and it can disrupt the skin barrier. SLES is a modified version meant to be less harsh, but the ethoxylation process introduces the 1,4-dioxane contamination risk.
Many clean brands use plant-derived alternatives: coco glucoside, decyl glucoside, or sodium coco-sulfate (different from SLS; derived from coconut). These clean effectively with a much lower irritation profile.
Phosphates (Historical Note)
Most U.S. household detergents have been phosphate-free since the 1990s when widespread water pollution forced the change. If you're using a product made in the last 20 years, phosphates probably aren't the issue. Mention only because some imported products still contain them.
The "Free & Clear" Trap
This is the biggest greenwashing pitfall in the laundry aisle. Brands like Tide Free & Gentle, All Free & Clear, and Arm & Hammer Sensitive are marketed to people with sensitive skin as a cleaner option. They're not.
"Free" typically means free of dyes and fragrance (or scent-free). It does not mean free of optical brighteners, 1,4-dioxane contamination, SLS, or synthetic enzymes. Tide Free & Gentle, for example, still contains optical brighteners and ethoxylated surfactants. It scored 7/10 (high hazard) on EWG's Guide to Healthy Cleaning.
When a mainstream brand makes a "free" version of their product, they're removing the dyes and scent — the things people directly notice and complain about. The less visible chemistry stays put.
What to Actually Look For
The Clean Detergent Checklist
- ✅ Plant-based surfactants (coco glucoside, decyl glucoside, sodium coco-sulfate)
- ✅ Full ingredient disclosure (every ingredient named, not "cleaning agents")
- ✅ No synthetic fragrance — essential oils only, or fragrance-free
- ✅ No optical brighteners
- ✅ No phosphates
- ✅ No 1,4-dioxane (confirmed by brand or absence of ethoxylated surfactants)
- ✅ Biodegradable formula
- ❌ "Fragrance" in ingredient list
- ❌ Sodium laureth sulfate or any "eth" ingredient
- ❌ Brightening/whitening claims without explanation
Certifications that help: MADE SAFE, EPA Safer Choice, EWG Verified. These require ingredient disclosure and screen for known hazards. They're not perfect, but they mean someone has looked at the formula.
Laundry Sheets vs. Liquid vs. Powder: Which Is Cleaner?
Each format has tradeoffs. Here's the honest breakdown:
| Format | Pros | Cons | Clean Brands |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liquid | Strong cleaning performance, good for stains, easy dosing | Plastic packaging, heavier shipping footprint | Branch Basics, Molly's Suds liquid |
| Powder | Low packaging waste, highly concentrated, no water filler, long shelf life | Can clump in cold water, some formulas leave residue | Meliora, Molly's Suds powder, Dropps powder |
| Sheets/Strips | Ultra-compact, plastic-free packaging, pre-measured, travel-friendly | Generally less concentrated, may underperform on heavy loads | Dropps, Tru Earth |
For pure cleaning performance, liquid and powder formulas still outperform strips, especially on heavy soiling or large loads. But for the environmentally-conscious who prioritize zero-plastic packaging and convenience, sheets are a genuine improvement over conventional liquid.
The criticism that "sheets don't actually clean" often comes from comparison to optical-brightener-heavy conventional detergent — which isn't actually cleaning better, just looking like it does. Clean laundry sheets clean clothes. They may not make whites look radioactively bright because they're not depositing UV-reactive chemicals on the fabric.
HE vs. Regular Machines
Most clean detergents are HE-compatible, but worth double-checking. High-efficiency machines use less water, which means sudsing matters — excess foam in an HE machine can affect the rinse cycle and leave residue.
Low-suds formulas work in both HE and conventional machines. Powder detergents tend to be HE-friendly. If you're using a concentrated liquid (like Branch Basics), the company's guidance on dilution ratios accounts for HE compatibility.
Top Clean Laundry Detergent Brands
Dropps
Format: Pods, laundry sheets EWG Certified: No, but transparent ingredient lists Best for: Convenience, low-waste lifestyle
Dropps pods use plant-derived surfactants and enzymes, no optical brighteners, no phosphates, and no dyes. Their packaging is cardboard (compostable). The pods are dissolvable in cold water, which matters since cold-water washing reduces energy use significantly. Fragrance-free and scented options available; the scented versions use fragrance oils, so fragrance-free is the cleaner choice.
Molly's Suds
Format: Powder, pods EWG Verified: Yes (powder formula) Best for: Sensitive skin, minimalists
Molly's Suds was built specifically for people with chemical sensitivities and skin conditions. The original powder formula has five ingredients: sodium carbonate (washing soda), sodium bicarbonate, magnesium sulfate, mineral salt, and peppermint essential oil. That's it. No surfactants at all in the base formula — it uses alkalinity to clean. EWG Verified. Excellent for sensitive skin, babies, and anyone reacting to even "clean" brands.
Meliora
Format: Powder, bar soap Certifications: MADE SAFE, B Corp, EWG Verified Best for: Zero-waste households, clean ingredient priority
Meliora's cleaning powder is certified by MADE SAFE, meaning every ingredient has been screened against known hazards. It's packaged in recyclable cardboard canisters. The formula uses sodium carbonate, sodium bicarbonate, and salt — simple, clean, and genuinely low-environmental-impact. Unscented and lightly scented (essential oil) options.
Seventh Generation ⚠️
A caveat before linking: Seventh Generation was acquired by Unilever in 2016. Unilever is one of the world's largest consumer goods conglomerates. Since the acquisition, Seventh Generation has largely maintained its ingredient standards and transparency practices, but they're no longer an independent company. Their products are still reasonably clean — no optical brighteners, plant-derived surfactants, EPA Safer Choice certified — but buying them is buying from Unilever.
Whether that matters to you is a values call. Ingredient-wise, Seventh Generation Free & Clear laundry detergent is a meaningful step up from Tide or Arm & Hammer. It's not in the same league as Molly's Suds or Meliora for minimalism or certifications, but it's widely available and a reasonable transition product.
Branch Basics
Format: Concentrated liquid (dilute yourself) Best for: Whole-home cleaning, households replacing multiple products
Branch Basics is a concentrate you dilute with water into multiple products — laundry, all-purpose cleaner, bathroom cleaner, dish soap. The laundry dilution is 1–2 tablespoons per load. Ingredients are fully disclosed, plant-derived, EWG Verified, and MADE SAFE certified. The plastic bottle is a concern (they do sell a starter kit with a glass bottle), but the concentrate-first model reduces overall plastic use vs. buying individual products.
It's more expensive upfront but cost-effective per load.
What About Fabric Softener and Dryer Sheets?
Standard fabric softener and dryer sheets are some of the worst products in the laundry room. They work by coating fabric fibers with chemicals — quaternary ammonium compounds (quats) or cationic surfactants — that feel soft but reduce absorbency in towels, coat moisture-wicking fabric, and off-gas fragrance chemicals through your dryer vent.
The clean alternatives:
- White vinegar in the rinse cycle — a half-cup reduces static and softens fabric through mineral removal, with no chemical residue. Don't use with bleach.
- Wool dryer balls — reusable, reduce drying time, and soften clothing through physical agitation. Add a few drops of essential oil if you want light scent.
- Avoid fabric softener on athletic wear and towels entirely — it degrades performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Seventh Generation really clean?
Better than conventional, not as clean as the best mineral-based options. Seventh Generation Free & Clear laundry detergent is EPA Safer Choice certified, uses plant-derived surfactants, and contains no optical brighteners or phosphates. But it's not EWG Verified, ingredient disclosure isn't as granular as Meliora or Molly's Suds, and it's owned by Unilever. If you're at a grocery store and can't find anything better, it's an acceptable choice. If you're ordering online, there are cleaner options available.
Are laundry sheets (strips) as effective as liquid detergent?
For light-to-moderate loads, yes. For heavily soiled clothes, large loads, or hard water, liquid or powder detergents generally outperform sheets. Sheets are convenient and have an excellent environmental footprint (plastic-free, lightweight shipping), but they're not maximally concentrated. If you wash mostly everyday clothes on normal settings, sheets will do the job.
What about fabric softener — are there clean versions?
There are "natural" fabric softeners on the market, but the category itself is problematic — they all work by coating fiber with chemicals that shouldn't be building up on clothes. The cleanest alternatives are white vinegar (rinse cycle) and wool dryer balls. If you need a commercial option for a specific reason, look for MADE SAFE certified products and avoid anything with "fragrance" in the ingredient list.
Does non-toxic detergent work in cold water?
Yes, most clean detergents are formulated to work in cold water. Plant-based enzymes (amylase, protease, lipase) that break down stains function across temperature ranges. Cold water is better for the environment and for your clothes; it's the recommended setting for most clean detergents.
What's the deal with enzymes in detergent — are they safe?
Enzymes (protease, amylase, cellulase, lipase) are biological molecules that break down specific types of stains: proteins, starches, cotton fibers, and fats. They're effective cleaners and far safer than synthetic cleaning chemicals. The concern people sometimes raise is about enzyme irritation — some people with sensitive skin react to enzyme-containing detergents. Molly's Suds and Meliora's powder formulas are enzyme-free options if you're sensitive.
Is powder detergent better than liquid?
For ingredient transparency and environmental footprint, often yes. Liquid detergents are mostly water — you're paying to ship water across the country. Powders are more concentrated by weight. They also have simpler preservative needs (no preservatives required since bacteria don't thrive without moisture). The downside is that some powders don't dissolve fully in cold water — pre-dissolving in a cup of warm water before adding to the wash fixes this.
Can I use these detergents for baby clothes?
Yes — in fact, clean detergents are the better choice for baby laundry. Babies have thinner, more permeable skin and are more vulnerable to chemical exposure. Look for fragrance-free formulas (no essential oils either for newborns) and enzyme-free if baby has particularly sensitive skin. Molly's Suds Original Powder and Meliora unscented are excellent starting points.